Initiative not to collect data on nation, religion and language in the census

Initiative not to collect data on nation, religion and language in the census

20/10/2020

The Centre for Democratic Transition (CDT), aiming to improve the democratic dialogue between relevant social actors on the future population and housing census (hereinafter: the census), and before the official public debate on the new draft law, extends the initiative:

To abandon, during the implementation of the next census, the practice of collecting data on ethnic (national) and religious (non-)affiliation, as well as on the language spoken by the citizens who are defined by the methodology as the subjects of the census.

This proposal is discontinuous with the current practice, the way in which the underlying principle of the census has been understood so far, the national policies related to it, but above all with the way in which relevant political, and other social actors behaved during its preparation and implementation.

The previous practice was not illegitimate, but it is, in our opinion, anachronistic. For that reason, we wish to present an alternative way of thinking in order to arrive at a different understanding of the underlying principle of this important social action.

This initiative is fully in line with the future EU obligations of Montenegro, which imply that censuses are conducted based on the data drawn from various registers, without the field collection of information from the citizens, because the traditional approach used for data collection and processing so far has proved to be out-of-date, obsolete, and less reliable.

During its 2016-2020 term, the Government of Montenegro initiated the preparatory activities in this direction, but they were not completed in due time, which is why the census is once again planned to be conducted in the traditional way.

The census is a statistical action aimed at facilitating, supporting, and directing state policies. However, there is a common opinion in Montenegro that the census is conducted so that its citizens may declare their religion, nation, and the language they use.

This brief overview of the need for information clearly suggests that data on ethnic, religious or linguistic affiliation do not have a particularly significant statistical value. Consequently, the key goal of their collection is political – not in terms of policy implementation, but in terms of conducting ethno-nationalist party policies, and continuing to manipulate the national and religious affiliations of citizens.

The adoption of our initiative would necessarily raise the question of how the current rights of the groups that are defined by our legislation as minorities will be realized. This refers most of all to the determination of the percentage of minorities required for the implementation of the Law on the Election of Councillors and Members of Parliament  and the Law on Minority Rights and Freedoms.

In order to determine these data, as prescribed by law, data from the previous censuses will be used, and in the case of major demographic changes (which are regularly monitored by official statistics), they can be verified through the conduct of appropriate official surveys. There is wide space here for the unhindered affirmation and protection of national and ethnic specificities of minority nations, but the census as such is not the way to achieve them.

A detailed explanation is available in the document.